The Identity Gap Assessment: Measuring Who You Are vs. Who You Want to Be
The distance between your current self and your ideal self isn't just a philosophical concept—it's a measurable gap that research shows directly impacts your mental health, motivation, and life satisfaction.
A groundbreaking study published in Frontiers in Psychology (2020) found that "identity gaps"—the discrepancies between how we see ourselves and how we want to be seen—are significantly associated with depression symptoms. The larger the gap, the greater the psychological distress.
What Is an Identity Gap?
Your identity gap represents the space between your actual self (who you currently are) and your ideal self (who you aspire to become). This isn't about self-criticism—it's about honest self-assessment. The research shows that acknowledging this gap is the first step toward closing it.
According to identity theory developed by Burkitt (2008) and expanded by scholars like McLean and Syed, our identity isn't fixed—it's a dynamic construction that we continuously negotiate through our actions, relationships, and self-reflection. The identity gap exists because we're always in a state of becoming.
"The self is not something ready-made, but something in continuous formation through choice of action." — John Dewey
The Four Dimensions of Identity Alignment
Research in self-concept and identity development has identified several key dimensions that determine how aligned you are with your ideal identity. Our Identity Gap Assessment measures four critical areas:
Self-Trust
Your ability to trust your own judgment and keep the promises you make to yourself. Research shows self-trust is foundational to identity coherence.
Clarity
How clearly you can envision who you want to become and what you truly value. Studies link identity clarity to higher well-being and purpose.
Alignment
The match between your daily actions and your stated values. Misalignment creates cognitive dissonance and undermines identity development.
Consistency
Your ability to follow through on commitments regardless of motivation. Consistency builds identity evidence and reinforces neural pathways.
The Science Behind Identity Gaps and Mental Health
The Frontiers in Psychology study (2020) by Jiyoung Park and colleagues examined how identity gaps relate to depression. Their findings were striking: individuals with larger discrepancies between their actual and ideal selves reported significantly higher levels of depressive symptoms.
But here's the empowering insight: the research also found that awareness of the gap—consciously acknowledging it—was the first step toward reducing it. Those who understood their identity gaps were better positioned to take action.
This aligns with Self-Discrepancy Theory developed by Edward Higgins (1987), which proposes that different types of self-discrepancies create different emotional vulnerabilities. The gap between actual and ideal selves relates to dejection-related emotions (disappointment, sadness), while the gap between actual and ought selves relates to agitation-related emotions (fear, anxiety).
What the Assessment Reveals
- 1Your overall identity gap percentage—how much room for growth exists
- 2Your dominant growth area—the dimension with the most opportunity for transformation
- 3Dimension-specific scores across self-trust, clarity, alignment, and consistency
- 4Actionable insights tailored to your unique gap profile
Why Measurement Matters
In behavioral psychology, there's a principle known as the Hawthorne Effect: people change their behavior when they know they're being observed. The Identity Gap Assessment creates a similar effect—by measuring your alignment, you become more conscious of it.
James Clear, author of Atomic Habits, emphasizes that identity change starts with awareness. You can't change what you don't measure. The assessment provides a baseline—a starting point from which all progress can be tracked.
Research on self-monitoring by psychologist Mark Snyder (1974) shows that individuals who regularly assess their behavior are better at aligning their actions with their goals. The Identity Gap Assessment makes this process systematic and measurable.
The Identity Gap Assessment is available at no cost. In just 3 minutes, you'll receive a comprehensive analysis of where you are versus where you want to be—across all four critical dimensions of identity alignment.
From Assessment to Action
Completing the assessment is just the beginning. The real transformation happens when you use the insights to guide your daily actions. Here's how the assessment connects to tangible change:
Identify Your Growth Edge
The assessment highlights your dominant growth area—the dimension where improvement will have the greatest impact on your overall identity alignment.
Set Evidence-Based Goals
With measurable scores, you can set specific targets for improvement and track your progress over time.
Connect to Transformation Tools
Your results point you toward specific tools and systems designed to close the gap in your dominant growth area.
The assessment is part of Tamkinly's FREE tier—our commitment to making evidence-based identity transformation accessible to everyone. Because everyone deserves the clarity that comes from understanding where they are and where they're headed.
Understanding your identity gap isn't about judgment—it's about awareness. It's about having the information you need to make conscious choices about who you're becoming. The gap exists whether you measure it or not. Measuring it simply gives you the power to close it.
Ready to Transform Your Identity?
You have read the theory. Now get the structured system that makes it automatic. Join thousands who turned insights into lasting identity change.